Re: [LAD] Realtime MIDI programming?

On Saturday, October 3, 2009, Albert Graef wrote:
> Harry Van Haaren wrote:
> > And I'd advise you to start with "normal" scheduling (I've never coded
> > an RT app, but MIDI apps works
> > 100% realtime for me without any upgrading of priority).
>
> That may work if you have enough spare cpu power, but otherwise you may
> get a lot of jitter which really hurts with fast pieces (lots of MIDI
> messages at a fast tempo).
>
> It's really not that hard to get realtime scheduling priorities on
> recent Linux systems. I wouldn't want to run any computer music
> application without that. But maybe RtMidi already does that behind the
> scenes?

No. And I don't feel it is needed at all, at least for VMPK (it is my only
program using RtMIDI at this moment).

If you are using Linux, the ALSA sequencer's MIDI routing and I/O is done in
kernel, which is usually good enough for realtime MIDI applications.

Answering to Carlo: RtMIDI is good if your goal is multiplatform (Linux, Win
and Mac) and your needs are basic. If your target is Linux only, I prefer to
work with the ALSA sequencer directly, using my wrapper for C++ and Qt4
(aseqmm).

Regards,
Pedro
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-dev mailing list
Linux-audio-dev@email-addr-hidden
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-audio-dev
Received on Sun Oct 4 20:15:02 2009