Subject: Re: [linux-audio-user] Re: Note tuning and quantizer in audio files
From: Them (idragosani_AT_chapelperilous.net)
Date: Tue Jul 06 2004 - 21:01:05 EEST
Alastair Couper wrote:
> The technology is interesting, to be sure. But what does it say about
> the state of artistry these days ? I recently read an interview with
> David Crosby, decrying the rise of autotune plugins and the like. He
> spent his energies on learning to sing on pitch. These days performers
> don't need to sing at all, they just mouth tracks that were autotuned
> in the studio. And another interview has James Brown saying: don't use
> a drum machine, learn to play the drums. The best music comes from the
> mastery of an instrument or vocal skill, not from editing.
> I have watched as I try various tools to bang my playing into shape,
> and am finally deciding that this is the wrong way to go. Spitiual
> death is around the corner. Live music is best. Music is meant to be
> PLAYED after all, not worked. Or worked over.
> A minority opinion from a nobody. Given the state of the "industry"
> though, it's going to be like Photoshop for audio, where there is no
> physical point of reference anymore, and anything can be morphed into
This is kinda what I was hinting at earlier... this kind of stuff tends
to sound over-produced and manufactured, IMHO. I think the life and
breath of music gets taken away by trying to make it too perfect sounding.
But as for using a drum machine, some of us have no choice. I don't
have the money to buy a full kit, let alone have the equipment to record
one, let alone have the time to take lessons to play at a skill level
high enough for the music I want to play. :-)
But I would never use a drum machine live. I'd hire a real drummer for
-- Rule of Feline Frustration: When your cat has fallen asleep on your lap and looks utterly content and adorable, you will suddenly have to go to the bathroom.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Tue Jul 06 2004 - 21:00:43 EEST