Subject: [linux-audio-user] Just how bad is USB audio?
From: Dan Armak (ermak@bezeqint.net)
Date: Sat Jan 25 2003 - 15:59:49 EET
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Hello,
I'm considering buying a USB sound card for my laptop. (I have no desktop box
worth talking about atm.) Everyone says a USB card is a Bad Thing, but I've
found few numerical measures, and I don't have much of a choice anyway
(unless someone releases a firewire card, or a pcmcica one under $1000)... If
someone can point me to some more concrete data, it would help me make my
choice. (Which is basically to buy or to suffer crappy sound, as I see no
real alternative...)
CPU utilization is the main problem. I probably wouldn't count as a hardcore
gamer, since I have a p3-900 with 256mb ram and it's enough to run all the
games I need (mostly ps1 emulations, but some sims/fpss too). So what
performance hit should I expect from using a usb audio device? The only
review on the net that actually mentioned numbers was one of the Extigy on
Tom's H/w Giude, and it said 20% cpu of a p4-2Ghz, but that was using 6 or 8
channels with special effects requested by something on the order of UT2003,
which is out of my league anyway.
I don't have or plan to have any other high-bandwith devices on my usb (1.1)
bus, just a keyboard/mouse/joystick. Also I only have 2 speakers atm, so I'll
only be streaming two channels. Therefore bandwith shouldn't be a problem as
I understand it.
OTOH I'd want to do some none-cpu-intensive work (writing, reading) while
listening to mp3s and copmpiling stuff in the backgruond. I would probably
accept some slowdown in the compiling, as long as the audio didn't skip and
responsiveness wasn't affected (I already use a kernel with all the low
latency/preempt/O1 scheduler etc. patches and have a prelinked system because
I really hate responsiveness issues)...
Finally as to the card itself: AFAICS there are the costly ones (Extigy and
Audiotrak Maya 5.1 usb), which have lots and lts of features most of which I
don't really need, and some cheap ones like the iMic or Xitel Hi-Fi-Link
which only have stereo rca input/output. The latter type is much closer to
what I'd be using of all those features, but unfortunately I cannot find them
in any shops here in Israel, and if I order over the internet I'll have to
pay for shipping and won't have warranty coverage. So I'd be willing to pay
for the maya card if I cuold be sure I'll be using it well, preferrably also
when I build my next desktop system in a year from now.
Any recommendations, info etc. will be most welcome :-)
- --
Dan Armak
Matan, Israel
Public GPG key: http://www.gentoo.org/~danarmak/danarmak-gpg-public.key
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.1 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQE+MphWUI2RQ41fiVERAsISAJ9Xxgimu2DETubVEdQ5faUUqjQTOACfWd+E
jT5Lw1WKA2aBteKTHPmn7Tg=
=wUPc
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b28 : Sat Jan 25 2003 - 16:28:02 EET