Re: [LAU] ABX test invite

On Fri, 2013-04-05 at 07:44 -0400, Thomas Vecchione wrote:
> As previously stated I do believe the AxelF sample is in the
> harder-to-encode region for MP3 encoders so I'm pretty sure my
> concentrated listening threshold for average music is
> somewhere around 130-140 kbps or so.
>
>
>
> Actually I really don't think it is. The material I mentioned will
> probably be much harder on it. And especially non-digitally recorded
> or mastered material, ie things with what would normally be considered
> 'noise'.

Hi :)

first off all, synth-pop could be a good source too, there are a lot of
Peter Gabrial recordings, that are better recorded than most classic
recordings, but for sure Axel F. is absolutely not useful for this test.

I've got a full analog recording of an Orchestra available,
unfortunately on a GEMA protected CD only [1].

It's not the kind of music I like, but theoretically it should be a
better source than Axel F., but when I listened to the CD, I noticed
that the CD already does sound like crap, so IMO there's the need to
have an original analog recording or a 48 KHz master for comparison.

Unfortunately it's not allowed to upload GEMA music, even not 5 or 10
seconds:
http://www.swishzone.de/software-allgemein/wieviel-sekunden-muss-gema-gebuehren-zahlen-8507.html#post65862
Since I know how often Dirk had disputes with people for nothing, I
won't upload it, while I don't guess that he or GEMA does follow LAU.
The composer can't decide to allow playing the music anymore, it's just
somebody else needed to contact the GEMA and they would sue me.

I recommend to delete the Axel F. upload, if it was done by using a
private IP.

Regards,
Ralf

[1]
"Die ganze Zeit"
Tim Isfort Orchestra with Katharina Thalbach & Blixa Bargeld

Orchestra recorded: Aula Adolfinun, Moers
Vocals recorded: AFN-Studio, Berlin
Recording: Stefan Höhnerbach (mixer), Dirk Brauner (microphony)
Assistants: Peter Spotka, Tilman Oeckinghaus, Christian Junk,
                    Harald Stark, Ralf Mardorf
Conductor: Malte Pagel
Director:
http://www.tim-isfort.de/Tim_Isfort/Work/Eintrage/2012/11/23_Tim_Isfort_Orchester.html

_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list
Linux-audio-user@lists.linuxaudio.org
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
Received on Fri Apr 5 16:15:03 2013